H2020 OLEUM Project: Advanced solutions to ensure the authenticity and overall quality of olive oil
- Type Project
- Status Filled
- Execution 2016 -2021
- Assigned Budget 4.878.860,87 €
- Scope Europeo
- Main source of financing H2020
- Project website Proyecto OLEUM
The OLEUM project will generate innovative, more effective, and harmonized analytical solutions to detect and combat the most common and emerging frauds, and to verify the overall quality of olive oils (OO). With a core group of 20 partners from 15 countries, OLEUM will undertake research activities based on the development of improved and new analytical methods through targeted and omics approaches with the aim of: detecting new markers of the soft deodorization process; uncovering illegal blends between OO and other vegetable oils; monitoring OO quality (e.g., freshness); improving organoleptic evaluation with a quantitative panel test, based on current official methods and supported by customized reference materials for better calibration of sensory panels, together with rapid screening tools to facilitate panelists' work.
The most promising OLEUM solutions will undergo validation in accordance with internationally agreed standards by peer laboratories. OLEUM will recreate a realistic deodorization scenario by producing customized, mild OOs, both in the laboratory and in larger-scale pilot plants, to apply analytical solutions to known samples. Significant knowledge and technology transfer activities are planned to facilitate the implementation of:
- A web-based, easily accessible, scalable, and constantly updated OLEUM database containing all the information from OLEUM research and other reliable international sources, which will be available for downloading data and spectra, and which will contribute to the successful harmonization of analytical approaches among control laboratories.
- The OLEUM Network of relevant stakeholders in OOs to maximize the impact of the proposed analytical solutions. Finally, a robust OLEUM project dissemination strategy, aimed at effectively sharing results with all stakeholders in the OO supply chain, has the potential to improve consumer and market confidence and preserve the image of OOs globally.
Taking into account the responses to the questionnaires sent to stakeholders and the EU National FFN Contact, an update on common and emerging frauds in the OO sector was presented. A selection was made from all the developed approaches to select four methods covering six SOPs that have undergone formal validation through an international collaborative trial:
- New/revised method for detecting illegal blends of OO with other vegetable oils: determination of free and esterified sterols
- Revised method for detecting blends of EVOO with mild deodorized OO (sdOO): determination of fatty acid ethyl esters (FAE)
- Method to be selected during the project: determination of phenolic compounds (health claim)
- Methods/tools to support the evaluation of sensory characteristics of EVOOs (quantitative panel testing): vinegariness and rancidity as sensory reference materials (RMs), untargeted SPME-GC-MS as a volatile-based screening approach, SPME-GC-FID and MS as targeted methods for the determination of selected volatiles.
The key outcomes of the validation studies were: an improved, internationally validated method for the quantitative determination of FAEEs; the first internationally validated method for the simultaneous quantitative determination of the minimum number of volatile compounds to support panel testing; an internationally evaluated volatile compound-based fingerprinting method to support official panel testing; and an international evaluation of the utility of the two proposed sensory RMs for assessor selection, training, and monitoring.
These methods will be proposed to the competent authorities and international organizations for inclusion in official regulations. For OA quality control: more than 300 commercial OA samples were analyzed using instrumental tools, and sensory evaluation was performed by six accredited panels. A decision tree was constructed for robust classification of the quality of each sample based on sensory results. Two new artificial sensory RMs were formulated and tested. Software was developed to estimate the deterioration in freshness/quality of OA.
A portable system for measuring free acidity and a rapid fluorescent method for detecting the total amount of lipophilic phenolic compounds were developed. For the authenticity control of vegetable oils (OO): samples of illegal blends (OOsd and vegetable oils) and legal blends (vegetable oils) with OO and EVOO were prepared and analyzed. A decision tree was developed for the detection of OO percentages in blends with other vegetable oils. More than 200 commercial OAs were analyzed to determine their compliance with the geographical origin declared on the label. The OLEUM Data Bank was launched, which aims to provide control bodies with a shared platform containing analytical data generated on OLEUM, along with sample information.
This will contribute to more effective collaboration and increased competitiveness among EU-authorized quality control laboratories. A wide range of national and international laboratories have received training in the new procedures and are now part of the OLEUM network of analysts and laboratories interested in olive oil analysis methods: the OLEUM LinkedIn group has over 140 members. For broad communication and dissemination, the project website is regularly updated and newsletters have been published. Infographics were developed to disseminate information about olive oil, as well as a project video. Twenty-two scientific articles were published, as well as several others in the media, and the project results were presented at conferences.
Europe accounts for more than 70% of global olive oil (OO) production; non-EU countries, traditionally importers, are also increasing their production. This, along with increased competitiveness, highlights the need to update and harmonize analytical methods to ensure the quality and authenticity of OO. OO's high price, its sensory profile, and its healthy reputation make it a target for fraud.
OLEUM's overall objective is to guarantee the quality and authenticity of OO through three strategic actions:
- Develop new and/or improved analytical methods.
- Establish an integrated online database, the OLEUM Database.
- Promote the OLEUM Network, a global community of OO sector stakeholders. OLEUM should address four main areas for improvement:
- Legislative and regulatory: developing solutions to support international regulators and policymakers.
- Analytics: Review existing analytical methods and develop new ones for OO quality and authenticity.
- Harmonization and coordination: Promote technology transfer to a broad community. A user-friendly OLEUM database will store data, analytical methods, and calibration materials.
- Consumer and market confidence: developing a simple and proactive dissemination strategy to promote the correct image of OO. OLEUM, coordinated by Prof. Tullia Gallina Toschi (University of Bologna), began in September 2016, has a 54-month duration, and involves 21 partners from 15 countries.
Virgin olive oils are known for their excellent nutritional and health benefits, but not all are created equal. OLEUM has revamped and revised its analytical procedures and tools to determine their quality and authenticity before they reach our shelves. Europe is the world's largest producer of olive oil. However, a combination of increasing competition, along with varying levels of regulation and knowledge, is increasing fraud, as indicated by a 2019 European Commission report.
To strengthen official controls and increase consumer confidence, the EU-supported OLEUM project has reviewed and revamped procedures to better ensure the quality and authenticity of olive oils. The project identified markers for soft deodorization, a technology used to eliminate or reduce sensory defects. The project developed tests for illegal blends with other vegetable oils and produced sensory reference materials to support panel testing. They also developed methods to monitor product freshness and predict shelf life. In addition, OLEUM developed a collaborative, open-source platform called the OLEUM Databank to host reference and calibration materials, along with a downloadable library of analytical methods. It also established the OLEUM Network, a global community of stakeholders, to share knowledge and results. “OLEUM methods should be adopted internationally to harmonize trade standards. Combining information on quality and authenticity with certified production volumes and their geolocation could form a blockchain to combat fraud,” explains Tullia Gallina Toschi, project coordinator at the University of Bologna, the project host.
Tools for Detection and Prevention The project’s initial research highlighted the problem of illegal blending of extra virgin olive oils with soft deodorized oils, especially re-milled or lampante oils, along with fraudulent modification of their natural color and aroma. Falsified claims of origin were also identified as a problem. To establish virgin olive oil quality and detect fraudulent blends, OLEUM developed tools for analyzing volatiles, along with sensory reference materials to support panel testing. Two methods were developed to detect fatty acid ethyl esters, the only officially recognized marker for fraudulent soft deodorization. Both are faster than pre-existing options.
One, which uses a preparative high-performance liquid chromatography step, was validated internally, while the other, which uses solid-phase extraction, underwent a successful peer-review study, the results of which will be published shortly. To strengthen product labeling, particularly regarding health claims for “olive oil polyphenols,” an ultra-high-performance liquid chromatography protocol was developed that allows for evaluation before and after hydrolysis, offering a more accurate picture. OLEUM also developed methods for assessing olive oil freshness, including software to predict the expiration date based on analytical parameters of acidity, peroxide value, and hydrophilic phenol concentration. This also takes into account light levels under storage conditions, which was validated in a real-time shelf-life experiment.
The OLEUM database, which hosts searchable real-time experiments, results datasets, and documentation, is open to public registration but could be restricted in the future to national official control bodies. “In collaboration with our OLEUM Network, this tool facilitates more effective collaboration and harmonization at a global level,” says Gallina Toschi. Responsible Consumption and Production To increase consumer awareness and confidence, OLEUM organized public activities at events such as the European Researchers’ Night and even in cooking schools, using materials such as multilingual infographics, videos, and games. Two OLEUM products have already been adopted by the market: stock solutions for analyzing volatile compounds and two sensory reference materials. The latter were made with volatile compounds that emulate the olfactory notes of rancid and vinegary aromas of virgin olive oils. “The main target markets are quality control laboratories.” There is no similar product on the market, and this approach could be extended to other food products," Gallina Toschi observes.
OLEUM is turning its objectives into concrete impacts targeting key players in the vegetable oil (OO) sector:
- The food industry and quality control laboratories: One of the main outcomes of OLEUM is the generation of two waves of new and revised methods for detecting fraud and verifying the quality of food. OLEUM is based on fully validated methods and reference materials, delivered to regulatory bodies and supplied to standardization organizations (IOC, EU, ISO, CODEX). The OLEUM database will multiply the dissemination of methods and data, with clear benefits for official quality control laboratories and the food industry. The existence and updating of the OLEUM database has already attracted the attention of relevant standardization bodies and stakeholders (e.g., ISO, AOCS, AOAC) and will enhance the reputation of EU foods. Data transferability is also linked to the need to improve the analytical expertise and competence of laboratories within the international food community. This should reduce litigation arising from the incorrect application of methods.
- International regulators and policymakers: OLEUM's impact lies in supporting the establishment of a harmonized anti-fraud system. OLEUM collaborates with various OO policymakers to find solutions that can be translated into recommendations and guidelines. OLEUM's impact also focuses on the ability to accelerate the adoption of validated procedures, thanks to collaborative testing conducted prior to proposal to regulatory bodies. During this process, new needs and challenges are identified through the continuous updating of quality and authenticity controls.
- Consumers and the OO Market: OLEUM promotes public understanding and awareness of the unique characteristics of OO, as well as better guarantees for the effective detection of illegal practices, thereby restoring consumer confidence and expanding accurate and direct knowledge about OO. One of OLEUM's innovations is its sense of responsibility, commitment to defending OO's reputation, sustainability aspects, and culture. This can be achieved by avoiding scandal and providing reliable and timely information. To this end, OLEUM is adopting various channels and tools, including, for example, visual games, simple answers to simple questions, and training sessions for the developed methods.
- ALMA MATER STUDIORUM - UNIVERSITA DI BOLOGNA (UNIBO)