H2020 PRIMAVERA Project: Process-based Climate Simulation: Advances in High-Resolution Modeling and European Climate Risk Assessment
- Type Project
- Status Filled
- Execution 2015 -2020
- Assigned Budget 14.967.969,5 €
- Scope Europeo
- Autonomous community Cantabria; Cataluña
- Main source of financing Horizon 2020
- Project website https://www.primavera-h2020.eu/
In the context of the CMIP6 exercise, PRIMAVERA has advanced the state of the art in global climate modeling by reducing the grid spacing of centennial-scale global simulations from 100 km to 25 km; developing and applying new physics parameterizations suitable for higher resolution; and coordinating the operation of seven 25-km models, run at different centers but all uploading data to a common analysis platform. Many of these developments are already being used in other new and existing projects. PRIMAVERA has further developed next-generation models in the sub-10-km range in both the atmosphere and ocean. Four groups ran simulations with an eddy-rich ocean, the initial results of which suggest the potential for significant changes in future climate risk in Europe compared to lower resolution, due to better representation of the Gulf Stream. Two groups also created 10-km and 5-km versions of their atmospheric model, which can be run with and without convection parameterization.
These were included in the DYAMOND project, which includes seven other international models with sub-5 km resolution, and show promise for the first time in the area of realistic tropical cyclone intensity and intensification. The ability to produce global, centennial-scale simulations at resolutions previously only possible with regional downscaling has allowed our community to engage stakeholders with local and global exposure. The data were used for the analysis of wind energy across a wide European domain, flooding due to extreme precipitation in several European basins, and also to enable the same studies, for companies with overseas interests, to be conducted in other regions.
A windstorm dataset for reinsurance and tropical cyclone risks in the Caribbean and Gulf of Mexico was also made possible by the exceptionally large sample provided by the PRIMAVERA ensemble, along with its ability to reproduce, for example, interannual TC variability and track location. The processes emerging in the PRIMAVERA models have already begun to address "off-track" behavior, that is, climate risks that are not represented in CMIP-type models due to biases.
A prominent example is post-tropical cyclones, intense mid-latitude storms of tropical origin, which can impact mid-latitude coasts with significant consequences. The promise of improved predictive capability resulting from improved simulation of eddy-mean flow interaction in the new generation of global models, likely down to 10 km, means that the investments we have made in advancing models and analyses provide a solid foundation for future progress.
PRIMAVERA produced a new CMIP6 simulation design, HighResMIP, shared our data and code for joint analysis on a common platform (JASMIN), and published the data in the CMIP ESGF archive for community use (about 12,000 simulation years, 1.7 PB, comparable to the entire CMIP5 archive). New functions (14) were developed and integrated into the community analysis package ESMValTool. We developed new model components suitable for higher resolution that will become standard in the next generation of climate models: aerosol microphysics, ocean mixing, sea ice melt ponds, land surface physics, stochastic physics schemes. We developed a new generation of models, using the eddy-rich ocean and sub-10 km atmosphere (and beyond in DYAMOND, at 5 km resolution), and an unstructured mesh sea ice and ocean model FESOM. To date, we have published 91+ peer-reviewed articles, with 54+ submitted or in preparation.
We found robust changes across the multi-model ensemble for several important climate processes, with several mechanistic chains better represented at higher resolutions (e.g., an enhanced Gulf Stream influencing the jet stream, storm tracks, and blocking). For our range of resolutions, the ocean provided the largest impact, and we showed that some changes with model resolution could lead to impacts that have implications for future climate change in Europe. This suggests that eddy-free simulations, such as those uniformly used in CMIP6, are missing key processes, which can significantly impact the resulting climate projections and risk assessments.
In addition to the peer-reviewed articles produced for scientific colleagues, we have contributed to and been widely cited in the IPCC's draft AR6 report, where CMIP6 HighResMIP is one of the exciting new sources of information also being used in national climate change assessments. We have used our website, user interface platform and associated data viewer, fact sheets, webinars, and story maps to engage with our end-users and others. We have actively collaborated with other European projects, sharing data, analysis, and insights, with several new projects building on the use of our data, code, or the models we have developed.
We have established strong links with many international communities (e.g., CLIVAR) and have ongoing collaborative analyses with many other groups (20–30 scientists have access to JASMIN) covering aspects such as climate extremes, storm and storm surge modeling. We organize sessions, public meetings, and side events at major conferences. During PRIMAVERA, many Master's, PhD, and postdoc studies have been initiated, which will continue beyond the project. There will be a legacy in the number of young researchers who have engaged with the project and whose research trajectories will be influenced by it. For example, a climate modeling summer school was held in 2019.
The overall objective of PRIMAVERA was to develop a new generation of advanced and well-evaluated high-resolution global climate models. PRIMAVERA experiments and deliverables, including CMIP6 HighResMIP, were designed to address some of the most pressing questions about regional climate change, in order to provide governments, businesses, and society with reliable information on weather and climate risk for the coming decades.
Our hypothesis was that many of the long-standing errors and biases in current models could be reduced by using much higher model resolutions (finer grids), so that key climate processes are better represented and the resulting projections are therefore more reliable. PRIMAVERA has fully achieved its goals of high-fidelity model development and simulation. All seven modeling groups used our common experimental design, HighResMIP, so that our simulations were comparable with each other and could be distributed to the wider climate community.
Consequently, we can now confidently and firmly say that increasing resolution improves climate simulation, and through our analyses and publications, this message has been clearly conveyed in the IPCC's draft AR6 report. Our further developments in the "Frontiers of Climate Modeling" work, down to even finer scales, pave the way for future projects, with initial results also indicating that European climate change projections may have been underestimated in current models.
PRIMAVERA was also designed to improve communication between climate scientists and society (from individuals and companies to policy advisors). We designed aspects of the project together with end users (e.g., renewable energy and reinsurance companies) and provided new types of information and products relevant to them (11 companies are interested in our windstorm dataset, and the user interface platform hosts accessible visualizations and other products from our website).
The objective of PRIMAVERA is to provide novel, advanced, and well-evaluated high-resolution Global Climate Models (GCMs) capable of simulating and predicting regional climate with unprecedented fidelity out to 2050. This capability will deliver innovative climate science and a new generation of advanced Earth system models. End-users from each sector, both political and business, will be identified and engaged individually, with iterative feedback, to ensure that new climate information is tailored, practical, and strengthens societal risk management decisions. These objectives will be achieved through the development of coupled GCMs from seven European clusters, with sufficient resolution to reproduce realistic weather and climate features (mesh size of approximately 25 km), in addition to improved process parameterization. A comprehensive evaluation will utilize innovative process-based metrics and the most recent observational and reanalysis datasets.
The dedicated experimental design will reduce inter-model dispersion and produce robust projections, constituting the European contribution to the PRIMAVERA-led High-Resolution Model Intercomparison Project (CMIP6). This is the first time that high-resolution coupled GCMs will be used under a single experimental protocol. The coordination and understanding of the underlying processes will significantly increase the robustness of our findings. Our new capabilities will be used to improve our understanding of the drivers of climate variability and change in Europe, including extremes, as these regional changes remain characterized by high uncertainty. We will also explore the frontiers of climate modeling and high-performance computing to produce simulations with reduced reliance on physical parameterizations. These will explicitly resolve key processes such as ocean eddies and include new stochastic parameterizations to represent sub-grid-scale processes. These "frontier" simulations will deepen our understanding of the robustness of climate projections.
Climate is fundamental to our lives, from food, water, and health to transportation and the economy. Given the reality of climate change, it is critical to better understand global climate processes and how they affect our weather and climate, both in the past and in the future. The EU-funded PRIMAVERA project has developed some world-leading global climate models that, coupled with advanced analytics, tell us more about the processes that have driven changes in weather and climate over recent decades and how they might unfold in the future. Higher resolution optimizes risk management. “Our seven modeling groups developed new global models with higher resolution (think of the pixel size of a camera; our new models have pixels 25 km wide, while standard models have pixels over 100 km) that could show us more detail, so we could better represent the weather and climate in Europe and around the world,” explains Malcolm Roberts, PRIMAVERA project coordinator.
By better modeling both large scales, such as the mid-latitude jet stream, and smaller scales, such as tropical cyclones and extreme storms, it is possible to better quantify future climate risk to people and infrastructure. In addition to modeling, the team developed new tools to analyze the huge volumes of data they produced. This allowed them to observe specific weather and climate characteristics (e.g., blocking, when high pressure remains in one place and can cause heat waves in the summer or cold waves in the winter) and whether these might change in the future. These new tools help optimize public and private sector decision-making and increase climate risk management capacity. PRIMAVERA's Data Viewer visualization tool provides an excellent illustration of what can be achieved when model resolution is increased. New climate simulations improve information The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) 7-Year Assessment Reports provide climate information from more than 40 international climate modeling groups.
However, due to the complexity and cost of running these models on large supercomputers, the spatial detail (resolution) is less than ideal, which can mean they fail to adequately represent some important weather and climate phenomena. PRIMAVERA addressed this by developing new climate simulation experiments that would be achievable with its significantly more expensive models and provide insights into what standard models might be missing. “In this way, we have managed to raise the bar for the quality of climate information and produced useful advice both in terms of policy and for some industry sectors, such as renewable energy, insurance, and energy networks,” says Roberts. How the reinsurance sector is benefiting The simulations provide new insights into improving climate models to produce more reliable projections of future changes. The project’s datasets (around 1.5 PB of data, equivalent to about 250,000 high-definition movies) are being used throughout the climate science community for research. The project team developed a catalog of windstorm events based on models that the reinsurance industry will use to assess risks due to storm damage.
- MET OFFICE
- THE UNIVERSITY OF READING
- ADMINISTRATIA NATIONALA DE METEOROLOGIE R.A.
- UNIVERSITE CATHOLIQUE DE LOUVAIN
- DEUTSCHES KLIMARECHENZENTRUM GMBH
- UNIVERSITY OF LEEDS
- SVERIGES METEOROLOGISKA OCH HYDROLOGISKA INSTITUT
- ALFRED-WEGENER-INSTITUT HELMHOLTZ-ZENTRUM FUR POLAR- UND MEERESFORSCHUNG
- CENTRE EUROPEEN DE RECHERCHE ET DEFORMATION AVANCEE EN CALCUL SCIENTIFIQUE
- PREDICTIA INTELLIGENT DATA SOLUTIONS SL
- UNITED KINGDOM RESEARCH AND INNOVATION
- CONSIGLIO NAZIONALE DELLE RICERCHE
- KONINKLIJK NEDERLANDS METEOROLOGISCH INSTITUUT-KNMI
- EUROPEAN CENTRE FOR MEDIUM-RANGE WEATHER FORECASTS
- THE CHANCELLOR, MASTERS AND SCHOLARS OF THE UNIVERSITY OF OXFORD
- NATIONAL OCEANOGRAPHY CENTRE
- MAX-PLANCK-GESELLSCHAFT ZUR FORDERUNG DER WISSENSCHAFTEN EV
- FONDAZIONE CENTRO EURO-MEDITERRANEOSUI CAMBIAMENTI CLIMATICI
- BARCELONA SUPERCOMPUTING CENTER CENTRO NACIONAL DE SUPERCOMPUTACION
- STOCKHOLMS UNIVERSITET
- Project website (CORDIS)
- CORDIS project factsheet (pdf)
- MET OFFICE website
- THE UNIVERSITY OF READING website
- UNIVERSITE CATHOLIQUE DE LOUVAIN website
- DEUTSCHES KLIMARECHENZENTRUM GMBH website
- University of Leeds website
- SVERIGES METEOROLOGISKA OCH HYDROLOGISKA INSTITUT website
- ALFRED-WEGENER-INSTITUT HELMHOLTZ-ZENTRUM FUR POLAR- UND MEERESFORSCHUNG website
- Website of CENTER EUROPEEN DE RECHERCHE ET DEFORMATION AVANCEE EN CALCUL SCIENT…
- PREDICTIA INTELLIGENT DATA SOLUTIONS SL website
- UNITED KINGDOM RESEARCH AND INNOVATION website
- CONSIGLIO NAZIONALE DELLE RICERCHE website
- KONINKLIJK NEDERLANDS METEOROLOGISCH INSTITUUT-KNMI website
- EUROPEAN CENTER FOR MEDIUM-RANGE WEATHER FORECASTS website
- Website of THE CHANCELLOR, MASTERS AND SCHOLARS OF THE UNIVERSITY OF OXFORD
- MAX-PLANCK-GESELLSCHAFT ZUR FORDERUNG DER WISSENSCHAFTEN EV website
- FONDAZIONE CENTRO EURO-MEDITERRANEOSU CAMBIAMENTI CLIMATICI website
- Website of the Barcelona Supercomputing Center
- STOCKHOLMS UNIVERSITY website
 
 
 
 
        
   
                         
             
            