H2020 Circular Agronomics project: efficient carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus cycles in the European agri-food system and related upstream and downstream processes to mitigate emissions
- Type Project
- Status Filled
- Execution 2018 -2023
- Assigned Budget 6.999.795,5 €
- Scope Europeo
- Main source of financing H2020
- Project website Circular Agronomics
Within WP2 and WP3, five innovative technologies have been developed to produce bioproducts and recover nutrients and carbon from different agri-food waste (water), while minimizing GHG and ammonia emissions (solar drying, microfiltration and fertigation, vacuum degassing, k-struvite recovery, and membrane treatment). Some of them have reached high TRLs (up to 7) and are now ready for operation. An operating brochure and an overview of other sites have been provided. Up to six bioproducts have been obtained that comply with the new European Fertilizer Regulation or struvite application requirements. We have been able to recover more than 83% of P in the form of struvite from soybean wastewater and up to 62% of N from manure digestate, which remains in the fertilizer in a more stable form. Ammonia emissions have been reduced by 86% with fertigation compared to business as usual, and by 23% during manure storage when using manure from precision feeding versus conventional feeding, while the acidification step during the solar drying process has reduced ammonia emissions by up to 90%.
To close the loop, the products generated in WP2 and WP3 have been tested in several agronomic/horticultural trials within WP1, and different strategies have been implemented to reduce nutrient surplus and increase nutrient use and C stocks (fertilization strategies, genotypic species, nitrification inhibitors, etc.). Some of the main results are: In long-term fertilization trials after seven years of organic fertilizer application, SOC stocks are >20% higher in the top 10 cm of soil compared to mineral fertilizer. Vacuum degassing of digestate limits N losses at a small cost to yield. Good potential for microfiltered digestate and dried acidified digestate to replace mineral fertilizer while reducing ammonia emissions.
In mixed farming systems, milk slurry from precision feeding is not as efficient a fertilizer as that from conventional feeding, but the crop protein content is higher. With phosphorus limitations, combining ryegrass and fescue allows for a considerable yield increase compared to their respective monocultures, while struvite as a P (and N) fertilizer maintains crop yield while significantly mitigating nitrous oxide emissions.
By applying different innovative strategies, it is possible to reduce nutrient surplus by up to 20% and increase nutrient efficiency and soil carbon stocks, both directly (fertilization strategies, genotypic species, nitrification inhibitors, etc.) and indirectly (by reducing/recovering N and P from manure and food waste [water]). A reduction in GHG and ammonia emissions of more than 15% can be achieved by applying strategies such as feeding, acidification or fertigation, while promoting the use of bio-based fertilizers that have been efficiently produced using the 5 innovative technologies developed (solar drying (TRL7), fertigation with microfiltered digestate (TRL8), vacuum degassing (TRL6), struvite recovery (TRL6) and membrane treatment (TRL6)).
Solar-dried fertilizers and microfiltered digestate fertilization are the most promising technologies from an environmental perspective, with the lowest impact, while precision feeding systems are the most cost-effective technology, with a 21% higher net farm income than the conventional system.
From a social perspective, farmers with eco-centric attitudes are more likely to adopt technologies that have demonstrated potential economic benefits. If farmers adopt these more sustainable, circular agricultural practices, consumers will be willing to pay a higher price for these sustainably produced food products.
Circular agronomy (CA) provides a comprehensive synthesis of practical solutions to improve the current cycling of carbon (C), nitrogen (N), and phosphorus (P) in European agroecosystems and the related upstream and downstream processes within the food production value chain. The proposed solutions would constitute a further step towards making agriculture an integral part of a circular economy by increasing resource efficiency while addressing associated environmental challenges, such as greenhouse gas and ammonia emissions, as well as the eutrophication of water bodies.
Through seven work packages and six case studies, representing locations with different biogeographical conditions and environmental challenges typical of the European agricultural sector, the CA aims to contribute to the development of sustainable, resilient, and inclusive economies that are part of circular and zero-waste societies.
The international, multi-stakeholder consortium involved aims to (i) increase the understanding of C, N, and P fluxes and the related potential to reduce environmental impacts at the agricultural and regional levels under different biogeographical conditions; (ii) close the loops of agriculture, from livestock to crop production, and increase the reuse of residues and wastewater from the food industry to improve soil fertility and increase nutrient use efficiency; (iii) highlight the performance of different agroecological system prototypes and increase the sustainability of food production in the EU; and (iv) contribute to the improvement of European Agricultural Policies through evidence-based, farmer-led, and consumer-relevant recommendations for the agri-food chain. The cross-cutting social, economic, and environmental assessment ensures the overall sustainability of the investigated solution.
At AC, an innovative approach (hyperspectral imaging) has been used to assess various soil chemical properties in an undisturbed, unmixed state at ultra-high resolution (~60 μm per pixel), enabling more sensitive analysis of soil profile changes. This has significantly improved our understanding of soil amendments in relation to carbon sequestration. AC has developed a novel approach that combines post-planting (inter-row) application of organic fertilizer with nitrification inhibitors. This combination has enabled cost-effective adjustment of nutrient availability and plant demand. Microfiltered digestate for fertigation (MDF) has proven to be a promising prototype for the direct use of liquid digestate for fertigation with drip irrigation lines, increasing nutrient use efficiency, reducing emissions, and minimizing water consumption. MDF has lower energy demands and is lower cost than membrane filtration. A new solar drying system has been developed to produce bio-based fertilizers.
In intensive dairy farming, CA has promoted the use of precision feeding systems in dairy cows to tailor nutrients to their needs and thus reduce nitrogen excretion in manure and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions by improving feed efficiency.
Furthermore, as part of the CA research focus, the isolation of potential bacteriophages has been investigated to control the number of ammonia-producing bacteria in the rumen of dairy cows. In extensive dairy farms, the CA focuses on cow physiology and compares different feeding strategies through the respiration chamber, which has made it possible to combine not only feeding with nutrient cycles, but also with gases and GHG emissions, studying the entire nutrient flow. Whey has been separated using innovative electrospun nanofibrous membranes, compared to recent technologies (ultrafiltration, reverse osmosis), with additional concentrate treatment (polishing, drying) for the sweet and sour whey food industry. The acid whey products will no longer be wasted but will be reused in livestock and agriculture. We have developed a novel nitrogen recovery technology, which can be integrated into existing biogas plants using sidestream treatment. Vacuum degassing can process mixed phases (solids and liquids; it does not require filtration or other excessive pretreatment), requires no additional heat, and is therefore more economical than stripping. A novel treatment using commercial enzymes has been developed to stimulate the release of phosphate from phytic acid. The process is flexible and adaptable to the treatment of residues and wastewater from soybean processing plants.
The project has a direct impact at the political/legal, environmental, social, technological, and economic levels. CA has contributed to the development of effective, collaborative policymaking by providing clear, evidence-based policy recommendations that will help policymakers identify policy barriers to closing nutrient cycles. Furthermore, the project has provided new input into CAP improvement debates, as our cutting-edge research has promoted new thinking in policymaking, for example, on the perception of the important role of carbon in agriculture, as well as on the risk vs. possibility debates related to the use of bio-based residues. CA has developed affordable technical solutions that fit into the current structures of European agriculture, minimizing the economic pressure on producers within the European agricultural sector to keep food production costs stable. The societal analysis within WP4 has led to the development of non-technical measures, such as policy actions, towards greater adequacy in agriculture, food consumption, and waste management.
- INSTITUT DE RECERCA I TECNOLOGIA AGROALIMENTARIES (IRTA - CERCA)